Author, date and country | Patient group | Study type (level of evidence) | Outcomes | Key results | Study Weaknesses |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Gupta. P et al 2004 India | 56 children aged 12 and under admitted for elective surgery. Divided into 6 age groups (0-1month, 1-6 months, 6months-2yrs, 2-6yrs, 6-14 yrs). | Cohort Study (level 3a) | Possible correlation between age, weight and fasting plasma glucose | Correlation not significant (p=0.828 for age and p=0.523 for weight) | Lack of Blinding. Method of randomisation not specified. Small sample size of 56 children. Lack of sample size estimates. |
Correlation between length of fast and plasma glucose level | Correlation not significant except in 2-6yrs age group where p=0.027 | ||||
Five patients showed signs of hypoglycaemia, only one of whom had a BM within the hypoglycaemic range (defined as <40mg/dl for neonates and <60mg/dl for infants and children). One child was hypoglycaemic but asymptomatic. | Child 1= Headache, age 1.5, fasted for 16 hrs, fasting plasma glucose of 100mg/dl (5.55mmol/L). | ||||
Bush. G et al 1996 United Kingdom | One four year old male child admitted for elective circumcision. He was fasted from midnight, and anaesthesia induced at 08.45am. | Case Study (level 4) | Severe Hypoglycaemia (with long term sequalae of epilepsy and cerebral damage) | Blood Glucose level of 1.7mmol/L measured at 21.25pm. Had probably dipped even lower prior to this reading. | Unknown whether hypoglycaemia would still have occurred in the absence of propranolol. Extremely small sample size (one child only). |
Somboonviboon. W et al 1996 Thailand | 84 healthy children aged 1 month to 13 years admitted for outpatient surgery. Divided into three groups according to age (Group 1 = <1year, Group 2= 1-5 years, Group 3 = 5+). Variation in length of time fasted according to age. Hypoglycaemia defined as BM <60mg/dL (3.33 mmol/L). | Cohort Study (level 3a) | Variations in length of time fasted according to age. | (Time in hours, Mean ±S.D) Group 1= 8.52±2.69 Group 2= 10.92±2.18 Group 3= 11.89±2.76 | |
Preoperative Blood Glucose level | (Time in minutes, Mean ±S.D) Group 1= 40.53±18.46 Group 2= 33.11±16.89 Group 3= 32.03±16.94 | ||||
Somboonviboon. W et al 1996 Thailand | 84 healthy children aged 1 month to 13 years admitted for outpatient surgery. Divided into three groups according to age (Group 1 = <1year, Group 2= 1-5 years, Group 3 = 5+). Variation in length of time fasted according to age. Hypoglycaemia defined as BM <60mg/dL (3.33 mmol/L). | Cohort Study (level 3a) | Variations in length of time fasted according to age. | (Time in hours, Mean ±S.D) Group 1= 8.52±2.69 Group 2= 10.92±2.18 Group 3= 11.89±2.76 | Lack of blinding. Lack of randomisation. No sample size estimates. Big variation in ages, and therefore fasting times, may cause inaccuracies. Variation in length of time under anaesthetic meant that postoperative readings were taken at different times between children. |
Variation in length of time under anaesthetic | (Time in minutes, Mean ±S.D) Group 1= 40.53±18.46 Group 2= 33.11±16.89 Group 3= 32.03±16.94 | ||||
Postoperative Blood Glucose level | (mg/dl ±S.d) Group 1= 129.07±37.90 Group 2= 115.62±29.63 Group 3= 111.53±23.07, No Significant correlation between length of fast and post-op BM (p >0.05) | ||||
Amponsah. G et al 1993 Ghana | 100 children admitted for surgery (60 major operations and 40 minor), divided into four groups according to age: Group 1= < 1 year (17 children) Group 2= 1-5 years (49 children) Group 3= 6-10 years (26 children) Group 4= >10 years (8 children) Hypoglycaemia was defined as blood sugar <4.4mmol/L. All patients had ‘overnight fast’ | Cohort Study (level 3a) | Variation in mean body weight between groups (Kg) | Group 1= 6.81 Group 2= 11.43 Group 3= 21.71 Group 4= 28.49 | Lack of Blinding Lack of randomisation No sample size estimates. Did the health of the children affect their physiological response to fasting? Variation in length of time fasted. 4.4mmol/L and below considered hypoglycaemic- too high? |
Variation in duration of starvation (hours) | Group 1= 14.1 ± 4.65, Group 2 = 14.98 ± 4.61, Group 3= 17.3 ± 2.73, Group 4= 17.2 ± 1.94 | ||||
Blood Sugar Concentrations (mmol/L) immediately post-induction | Group 1= 4.14± 1.1, Group 2= 4.06 ±0.96, Group 3= 4.47± 0.79, Group 4= 4.7 ± 0.83 | ||||
Percentage of patients who were defined as hypoglycaemic ( BM <4.4 mmol/L) | Group 1= 65%, Group 2= 61%, Group 3= 50%, Group 4= 25% | ||||
Shah. M et al 1990 Pakistan | 104 children aged 6 months – 10 years, undergoing inpatient anaesthesia for minor procedures (e.g. tonsillectomy). All were fasted from midnight the night before until induction of anaesthetic (mean 10.87hrs ±2.68hrs). | Cohort Study (level 3a) | Pre- induction hypoglycaemia (mmol/L) (defined as blood sugar of 2.7-3.5 mmol/L) | Detected in 4 children (5.8%), distributed as follows: Child 1- 1 year old girl, fasted for 9hrs total, Pre induction BM=3.3. | |
Increase in Blood Sugar seen in samples taken 30 minutes after induction in hypoglycaemic children (except in one case) (mmol/L) | |||||
Possible correlation between pre-induction BM and age | |||||
Shah. M et al 1990 Pakistan | 104 children aged 6 months – 10 years, undergoing inpatient anaesthesia for minor procedures (e.g. tonsillectomy). All were fasted from midnight the night before until induction of anaesthetic (mean 10.87hrs ±2.68hrs). | Cohort Study (level 3a) | Pre- induction hypoglycaemia (mmol/L) (defined as blood sugar of 2.7-3.5 mmol/L) | Detected in 4 children (5.8%), distributed as follows: Child 1- 1 year old girl, fasted for 9hrs total, Pre induction BM=3.3, Child 2- 2 year old boy, fasted for 13hrs total, Pre induction BM= 3.3, Child 3- 3 year old boy, fasted for 10hrs total, Pre induction BM= 3.2, Child 4- 4 year old boy, fasted for 15hrs total, Pre-induction BM= 2.7 | Lack of Blinding No randomisation Lack of sample size estimates No information given about contents of pre-medication Children used may respond differently to fasting than those living in the developed world. |
Increase in Blood Sugar seen in samples taken 30 minutes after induction in hypoglycaemic children (except in one case) (mmol/L) | Increase between pre to post-induction BM- r= 0.466 | ||||
Possible correlation between pre-induction BM and age | No significant corellation (r=0.068) | ||||
Aun. C et al 1990 United Kingdom | 20 healthy children aged 1-5years presenting for minor surgery. All were given a milk-based drink at midnight, then nothing further was given. Then randomly allocated into two groups according to feed given 4hrs before surgery. Group 1 were given nothing/water Group 2 were given 5% dextrose solution. | Randomised control trial (level 1b) | No preoperative hypoglycaemia was found in either group | Average Blood Sugar (mmol/L) Group 1= 4.64, Group 2= 4.58 | No sample size estimates. Lack of blinding. Method of randomisation not stated. Time when last solid food given is not specified. The pre-med given to all children was sugar based. |
Plasma glucose found to be increased intra-operatively and post operatively when compared to pre-op values. Peak at 30 mins post op. | Increase statistically significant (p <0.01) | ||||
Mean plasma glucose thought to be higher in fasted group. | No significant difference between groups. | ||||
Increased concentrations of glucagon, cortisol and growth hormone postoperatively. | Increase from pre-operative values statistically significant (p<0.01) | ||||
Correlation between volume of gastric contents (aspirated immediately after induction) and age. | Significant correlation in the fasted group (p=0.03) | ||||
Correlation between volume of gastric contents (aspirated immediately after induction) and body weight. | Significant correlation in the fasted group (p=0.02) | ||||
Long. T et al 1989 United Kingdom | One 6 year old boy admitted for adenotonsillectomy. He was fasted from midnight until anaesthesia was induced | Case Report (level 4) | Symptoms of profound hypoglycaemia were experienced when attempting to induce anaesthetic | At 10.45 am, fingerprick glucose measurement estimated a blood sugar reading of 2mmol/L. Analysis of plasma glucose showed blood glucose to be 3.2mmol/L. | Small sample size of 1 child. Conducted retrospectively. |
O'Flynn. P et al 1989 United Kingdom | 34 healthy children (aged between 11 and 99 months) admitted for daycase grommet insertion. All were instructed not to eat after midnight the night before surgery. | Cohort Study (level 3a) | Large variation in length of time between last meal and induction of anaesthesia | Parents advised to fast children from midnight but many were fasted much longer | No sample size estimates. Small sample size of 34 children. Lack of blinding and randomisation. |
Preoperative hypoglycaemia | Found in 3 of the 34 children (8.8%) at induction. Blood sugars (mmol/L) were as follows: Child 1= 2.3 Child 2= 2.7 Child 3= 2.9 | ||||
Van der Walt et al 1990 Australia | 62 infants aged less than three months presenting for routine surgery. Divided into two groups according to which feed they were given 4 hours pre-operatively. Group 1- Breast Milk (30 infants) Group 2- Formula Milk (32 infants) After this feed, all infants were fasted. | Randomised Control Trial (level 1b) | Variation in age between groups | Average age for groups (days): Group 1= 48 ±24, Group 2= 72± 22 | Lack of Sample size estimates. No blinding. No randomisation. |
Blood Sugar measured at induction of anaesthesia. | No hypoglycaemia in either group | ||||
Blood sugar measured intraoperatively, in some cases following the administration of IV fluids | No hypoglycaemia in either group | ||||
Welborn. L et al 1986 United States of America | 446 healthy children aged 1 month- 6 years, presenting for minor surgery. Divided into two groups according to intraoperative fluids given: Group A – Lactated Ringer’s solution Group B- 5% Dextrose and Lactated Ringer’s solution. All fasted from midnight, but allowed clear fluids thereafter until 4-6hrs before surgery. | Randomised Control Trial (level 1b) | Variation in mean fasting time (hours), dependent on age | 0-1 years= 6.1, 1-2 years= 11.0 , 2-4 years= 12.2, 4-6 years= 12.7 | Lack of blinding Method of randomisation not specified No sample size estimates Wide range in time initial blood sample was taken |
Two cases of hypoglycaemia at induction | Blood sugars of 2.61mmol/L and 2.2mmol/L at induction of anaesthesia. Both occuring in children who had a prolonged fast. | ||||
Increase in pre-operative-post operative blood glucose values (mg/dl) | Increase from pre-op to post-op BM was statistically significant across all groups (p<0.0001) | ||||
Van der walt. J et al 1986 Australia | 123 infants aged between 5 days and 12 months presenting for routine surgery. Fasted for 6hrs pre-op, then randomly allocated into one of four groups according to feed given 3-4 hrs pre-op. Group 1-20% Poly Joule Group 2- 5% Dextrose Group 3- Cow’s Milk Group 4- Control Group Hypoglycaemia defined as plasma glucose <2.2mmol/L | Randomised Control Trial (level 2a) | Plasma glucose (mmol/L) measured immediately before induction of anaesthesia | No hypoglycaemia in any group | Lack of blinding. Method of randomisation not specified. Lack of sample size estimates. Large variation in length of fast. |
Plasma glucose (mmol/ L) measured 5 minutes after induction | No hypoglycaemia in any group | ||||
Difference between pre and post-induction plasma glucose measured (mmol/L) | Increase statistically significant (p<0.001) | ||||
Redfern. N et al 1986 United Kingdom | 54 healthy children children aged between 1 and 5 years. Divided into two groups according to scheduling of surgery. Group 1- fasted from midnight the night before. Morning surgery. Group 2- given cereal at breakfast time them fasted for afternoon surgery. | Randomised Control Trial (level 1b) | Mean fasting time | Significantly longer for patients fasted overnight for morning surgery (mean 14.9 hrs) than those in afternoon (mean 8.8hrs) (p<0.001) | No sample size estimates. Lack of blinding. Method of randomisation not specified. Pre-med contained sugar so may have affected blood glucose concentrations. |
Mean post-induction glucose level | Slightly lower in afternoon group (mean 4.4mmol/L) than morning group (4.8mmol/L) (despite shorter fast) (P<0.05) | ||||
Possible correlation between length of individual fast and post-induction blood glucose level | No significant corellation between length of fast and blood sugar | ||||
Intraoperative increase in glucose level compared to pre-op | Significant increase in both groups (p<0.001) | ||||
Hypoglycamia (defined as BM< 2.6mmol/L) | No hypoglycaemia in either group | ||||
Payne et al 1984 United Kingdom | 100 healthy children under 5 years and under 20Kg weight. Divided into two groups- those under and those over 1 year old. They were further subdivided according to weight- those below the 3rd centile, those between the 3rd and 25th centiles and those over the 25th centile. Children fasted from midnight, those under 1 given milk at 02.00am. All children recived 5% dextrose solution according to weight 4 hours before surgery. | Randomised control trial (level 1b) | Those children below the 3rd centile for weight are more likely to become hypoglycaemic (defined as BM < 3mmol/L) | In those children over 1 year of age (group A), there was a statistically significant tendency to develop hypoglycaemia (8 out of 22 children were shown to have a BM <3mmol/L before or immediately after induction) (p<0.05) | Lack of blinding. Method of randomisation not specified. No sample size estimates. Confusing grouping of patients. |
Two cases of extremely low plasma glucose in children below the 3rd centile. | Seen in two two-year old marasmic children weighing 9kg and 8.3kg. Post induction their BMs were 1.8mmol/L (child 1) and 2.8mmol/L (child 2). Child 1’s BM increased slightly post-op to 3.3mmol/L, but child 2’s BM decreased post-operatively to 1.9mmol/L. | ||||
Two cases of hypoglycaemia in children above the 3rd centile. | Both aged <15 months, with pre-op fasts of 7.5 and 10hours. | ||||
Srinivasan. G et al 1986 United States of America | 16 infants and neonates scheduled for elective surgery with baseline glucose levels <150mg/dl (8.33mmol/L) | Cohort Study (level 2b) | Possible correlation between blood glucose concentration and weight | Postsurgical plasma glucose levels showed negative correlation with weight (p<0.01) | Length of fast not specified. Very small sample of 16 children. No sample size estimates. Lack of blinding or randomisation. |
Some post operative hyperglycaemia | Seven infants had blood sugars higher than 13.8mmol/L. On average these children were lighter than those children who did not develop hyperglycaemia (p<0.01) | ||||
Significant inrease in blood glucose post-operatively from pre-op value | p<0.01. Non hypoglycaemia in any child. | ||||
Nilsson. K et al 1984 United Kingdom | 70 healthy children under 2 years. All were given breast milk 4 hours before start of surgery. Then divided into two groups: Group A received Ringer acetate solution intraoperatively Group B received ringer acetate with 2% glucose | Randomised control trial – level 1b. | Group given glucose had larger increase when comparind pre and post-operative BMs | Difference significant (p<0.001) | No definition of hypoglycaemic range Lack of Blinding Method of randomisation not specified Small sample of 70 No sample size estimates |
No post-operative hypoglycaemia | Lowest recorded BM= 2.9 | ||||
Jensen et al 1982 United Kingdom | 134 healthy children admitted for minor surgery. Divided into inpatient and outpatient groups. Further subdivided according to age: Group I- children <4yrs Group II- children >4yrs All outpatients were fasted from bedtime. Inpatients were divided into two groups: Group A were fasted from bedtime (46 children, of whom 24 were under 4 years(Group I)). Group B were given a fruit syrup in amounts according to body weight (36 children, of whom 15 were under 4 years (group I). | Randomised control trial- 1b. | Potential difference in blood glucose concentrations between inpatients and outpatients | No significant difference between groups. | Lack of blinding. Method of randomisation not specified. No sample size estimates. Confusing grouping of patients. |
Possible correlation bertween length of fast and post-operative blood sugar | No correlation in any group (p>0.1) | ||||
Children over 4 years given fruit syrup had significantly higher blood sigars than those fasted from midnight | (0.02 | ||||
Allison et al 1982 United Kingdom | 92 children aged between 8 months and 8 years, fasted overnight prior to anaesthesia. | Cohort Study (level 2b) | Symptomatic hypoglycaemia | None of those children becoming hypoglycaemic were symptomatic | No sample size estimates. Lack of blinding or randomisation. |
Hypoglycaemia (defined as blood sugar <3.3mmol/L) | Overall (n=92), 11% of children became hypoglycaemic. In the group of children under 4 years old (n=30), 23% became hypoglycaemic. | ||||
Severe hypoglycaemia (blood sugar < 2.2mmol/L) | One child (3%) had a blood sugar <2.2mmol/L | ||||
Risk of hypoglycaemia related to weight of the child | Those children under the 25th centile for weight (n= 28) had a mean plasma glucose of 4mmol/L. Those children above the 25th centile had an average BM of 4.6mmol/L. | ||||
Bevan et al 1978 United Kingdom | 243 healthy children aged 5 months – 12 years undergoing inpatient procedures. Divided into two groups: ‘Starved Group’- 142 children, fasted overnight if morning surgery, or for at least 8hrs if in afternoon. ‘Fed Group’ – 101 patients. Given ‘gastro-caloreen’ (a glucose polymer dissolved in water) 3-5 hrs after the previous night’s evening meal. Given more at 06.00 on day of surgery and every 4 hrs thereafter until 3-4 hours before surgery. | Randomised control trial (level 1b) | Mean blood glucose higher in fed patients than starved. | In the ‘starved’ group twenty-four | Does not taken into account protein requirement (only carbohydrate) Lack of blinding. Method of randomisation not specified. No sample size estimates. Does not mention that giving sugar may affect insulin secretion. |
Ffoulkes. D et al 1976 Nigeria | 28 healthy children between 2 months and 15 years. BM was measured 15 minutes before anaesthesia, 15 minutes after induction and 15 minutes after start of surgery. | Randomised control trial- level 1b. | Two cases of hypoglycaemia (defined as BM <45mg/dl) | Children had pre-anaesthetic BMs of 45mg/dl (2.77mmol/L) and 27mg/dl (1.5mmol/L) respectively. | Lack of blinding. Method of randomisation not specified. Small sample size of 28. No sample size estimates. No p values given therefore difficult to assess validity. |
Cases of hypoglycaemia occurred in children under 2 years weighing 3.2-12.7Kg. | Children under two with lower body weights had lower blood sugars than heavier children, following a comparative fast. ?statistically significant | ||||
Ware et al 1976 United Kingdom | 57 children under 4 years old undergoing surgery. | Cohort study (level 3a) | Six children were found to be hypoglycaemic post operatively overall, many of whom were below the 10th centile for weight | Mean pre-op glucose in children below the 10th centile= 52.6±16.1, Mean pre-op glucose in children above the 10th centile= 64.5±19.7, (0.2>P>0.1, said to be statistically significant using students t test) | Dextrostix used to measure blood glucose and may have been inaccurate in some cases. No sample size estimates. Relatively small sample of 57 children. Lack of blinding and randomisation. |
2 hours postoperatively, one child was hypoglycaemic | Blood sugar of 37mg/dl (2.05mmol/L) | ||||
4 hours post –op, three were hypoglycaemic | Blood sugars of 1.83, 1.55 and 2.05 (mmol/L) | ||||
6 hours post-op, two children were hypoglycaemic | Blood sugars of 1.88 and 2.05 (mmol/L) | ||||
Thomas et al 1974 United Kingdom | 62 children aged between 19 months and 166 months, undergoing afternoon surgery for correction of strabismus. All children were fasted overnight then received a bowl of cereal at 06.00. Divided into two groups: Starvation group (SG) received no further food. Milk Group (MG) were given milk to drink 4 hrs before surgery. | Randomised control trial (level 2a) | Group given glucose had higher mean blood glucose | Difference between groups significant (p<0.0005) | No sample size estimates. Realtively small sample size of 62. Lack of blinding. Method of randomisation not specified. |
Cases of hypoglycaemia different between groups | In the milk group, no hypoglycaemia occurred. In the starved group, 15.2% were hypoglycaemic (BG<40mg/dl (2.22mmol/L)). Difference between groups significant (p=0.05) | ||||
Within the starvation group, the smaller children were the ones who became hypoglycaemic | Children in SG <47months old and <15.5Kg (18 children)= 5 became hypoglycaemic (28%), Children in SG >47months old and >15.5Kg (15 children)= none were hypoglycaemic. | ||||
In children <47 months old and <15.5Kg in weight, there were differences in blood sugar between the MG and the SG | Starved group mean blood sugar level = 46.4mg/dl (2.57mmol/L), Milk Group mean blood sugar level = 60.0 (3.33mmol/L), Difference significant between groups (p<0.0005) | ||||
Watson et al 1972 United Kingdom | 80 children between 22 months and 15 years presenting for surgery (combination of major and minor. | Randomised control trial (level 1b) | Overall increase in blood glucose concentrations in response to surgery | Increase from pre-operative to post-operative values were statistically significant (p<0.001) | Length of pre-operative fast not specified. Lack of blinding No sample size estimates Method of randomisation not specified |
Eight patients (10%) were hypoglycaemic pre-operatively (defined as blood sugar < 40mg/dl) | The following blood sugars were recorded at induction (mmol): 28, 40, 38, 30, 30, 40, 30, 25. No significant correlation between type of surgery (major/minor), or length of fast and risk of hypoglycaemia. |