Author, date and country | Patient group | Study type (level of evidence) | Outcomes | Key results | Study Weaknesses |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Ingebrigtsen, et al. 1999 Sweden | 50 patients with minor head injury within 12 hours of injury. GCS 13-15. Loss of Consciousness (LOC) <20min or amnesia. Age 12-72yrs. No focal neurological deficit. No CT evident injury on initial report. CT review showed 4 abnormal CTs – 4 fractures, 2 of which had contusion on CT. Index test: Serum S100B (Sangtec Medical AB, cut-off 0.20 µg/L (assay lowest detection limit), taken ≤ 12 hrs from injury. Gold standard: MRI, Positive CT scan. | Prospective cohort | Sensitivity | 1.00 | Originally designed to compare serum S100B with MRI. All patients had normal initial CT. Subsequently 4 CTs found abnormal on 2nd report. Selection bias. Neurosurgical referred population. Age 10-72 yrs. Not powered. No blinding. |
Specificity | 0.77 | ||||
PPV | 0.21 | ||||
NPV | 1.00 | ||||
LR+ | 4.34 | ||||
LR- | 0 | ||||
Ingebrigtsen, et al. 2000 Sweden | 182 patients with minor head injury within 12 hrs of injury. ≤10min LOC, GCS 13-15. No focal neurological deficit. Age 15-80 yrs. Index test: Serum S100B (LIA, Sangtec), cut-off 0.20 µg/L (lowest detection limit), taken ≤ 12 hrs. Gold standard: Positive CT scan, within 24 hrs of injury. | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.10 | Selection bias. Age ≥15 yrs. Small study over 28 month period. Not powered. No precision analysis. No blinding. S100B sampled within 12 hrs. Extracranial injuries not excluded |
Sensitivity | 0.90 | ||||
Specificity | 0.65 | ||||
PPV | 0.13 | ||||
NPV | 0.99 | ||||
LR+ | 2.57 | ||||
LR- | 0.15 | ||||
Biberthaler, et al. 2001 Germany | 52 patients with isolated head injury GCS 13-15 + One of: Amnesia, LOC, nausea, vomiting, vertigo or severe headache. No focal neurological deficit. Control groups: +ve (severe) n=20, -ve (healthy) n=10. Index test: Serum S100B (LIA, Sangtec), cut-off 0.10 µg/L, sampling time from trauma 116±18 min. Gold standard: Positive CT Scan ≤ 6 hrs after injury. | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.28 | Selection bias (high prevalence). Small study. Not powered. No precision analysis. No blinding. No age specified (adults according to personal correspondence). Convenient cut-off level taken to achieve 1.0 sensitivity. No ROC curve analysis. |
Sensitivity | 1.000 | ||||
Specificity | 0.405 | ||||
PPV | 0.405 | ||||
NPV | 1.000 | ||||
LR+ | 1.680 | ||||
LR- | 0 | ||||
Mussack, et al. 2002 Germany | 139 adults with: Isolated head injury GCS 13-15 + One of: Transient LOC <5 min, Amnesia, Nausea, Vomiting, Vertigo. Index test: Serum S100B (LIAISON Sangtec)cut off 0.21 µg/L Median sample time 24.3 min (IQR 18-62.5) Gold standard: Positive CT scan | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.137 | Selection bias: High prevalence, Oktoberfest population, only 19 sober patients. Consecutive sample over 18 days. Small study, not powered. No blinding mentioned. Short sampling time of 24.3 min(IQR 18-62.5 min) - difficult to replicate in practice. Limited precision analysis. |
AUC (at cut-off 0.21 ug/L) | 0.86 (95%CI 0.78-0.94) | ||||
Sensitivity | 1.00 | ||||
Specificity | 0.50 (95%CI 0.49-0.59) | ||||
PPV | 0.24 | ||||
NPV | 1.00 | ||||
LR+ | 2.0 (95%CI 1.70-2.44) | ||||
LR- | 0 | ||||
Biberthaler, et al. 2002 Germany | 104 patients with: Isolated head injury within 2 hrs of injury, GCS 13-15 + One of: Transient LOC (<5 min), Amnesia, Nausea, Vomiting, Vertigo. Severe headache. Index test: Serum S100B(LIAISON Sangtec)cut-off 0.12 µg/L, taken ≤2 hrs from injury. Gold standard: Positive CT Scan. | Prospective Cohort | Prevalence | 0.23 | Selection bias. Small study over 18 months. Not powered. No blinding mentioned. Sampling time ≤2 hrs not practical. Limited precision. |
AUC | 0.79 (95%CI 0.70-0.89) | ||||
Sensitivity | 1.00 | ||||
Specificity | 0.46 | ||||
PPV | 0.35 | ||||
NPV | 1.00 | ||||
LR+ | 1.85 | ||||
LR- | 0 | ||||
Biberthaler, et al. 2004 Germany | 75 patients with: Isolated head injury presenting within 2 hrs of injury, GCS 13-15 + One of: Transient LOC (<5 min), Amnesia, Nausea, Vomiting, Dizziness, Severe headache. Index test: Serum S100B (Elecsys S100, cut-off 0.14 µg/L, taken ≤2 hrs. Gold Standard: Positive CT Scan. | Prospective cohort – pilot study | Prevalence | 0.19 | Small study - not powered. Selection bias. No blinding mentioned. Sampling time ≤2 hrs not practical. Pilot study – Basis for multicentre study. |
AUC | 0.88 (95%CI 0.80-0.96) | ||||
Sensitivity | 1.00 (95%CI 0.75-1.00) | ||||
Specificity | 0.66 (95%CI 0.54-0.78) | ||||
PPV | 0.40 (95%CI 0.24-0.56) | ||||
NPV | 1.00 (95%CI 0.89-1.00) | ||||
LR+ | 2.27 | ||||
LR- | 0 | ||||
Nygren de Boussard, et al. 2004 Sweden | 66 patients with: Isolated head injury within 24 hrs of injury, Age 15-65 yrs, GCS 14-15. + One of: LOC <30 min, Amnesia <24 hrs. No other major injury. Index test: Serum S100B ≤24 hrs (LIA-mat S100 Sangtec)cut-off 0.15 µg/L, 0.10 µg/L using Unden meta-analysis. Gold standard: Positive CT Scan ≤24 hrs, MRI ≤7 days. | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.06 | Small sample. Selection bias. Not powered. No blinding mentioned. Sampling up to 24 hrs. Outcome CT and/or MRI pathology (all patients had a CT scan) CT outcome measure results (without MRI) obtained only using Unden et al meta-analysis. |
Sensitivity at 0.15ug/L cut-off | 0.80 | ||||
Using Unden meta-analysis | at 0.10 ug/L cut-off | ||||
Sensitivity | 1.00 | ||||
Specificity | 0.47 | ||||
PPV | 0.11 | ||||
NPV | 1.00 | ||||
LR+ | 1.88 | ||||
LR- | 0 | ||||
Poli-de-Figueiredo et al 2006 Brazil | 50 patients with: Isolated head injury GCS 13-15 + One of: Amnesia, LOC, Nausea, Vomiting, Vertigo, Severe headache, No focal neurological deficit. Index test: Serum S100B(Elecsys 2010), cut-off 0.10 µg/L. Median sample time 82 min (IQR 60-110 min). Gold standard: Positive CT Scan ≤6 hrs from arrival. | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.12 | Small sample, No age specified, (in separate study Lima et al showed 39 out of 50 cases had mean age 39±2.87). Selection bias. No blinding mentioned. Not powered. No precision analysis. Samples transported deep frozen for analysis in Germany. |
AUC | 0.82 (95%CI 0.69-0.96) | ||||
Sensitivity | 1.00 | ||||
Specificity | 0.20 | ||||
PPV | 0.15 | ||||
NPV | 1.00 | ||||
LR+ | 1.25 | ||||
LR- | 0 | ||||
Bazarian, et al. 2006 USA | 96 patients with minor head injury within 4 hrs of injury + One of: LOC <30 min, Amnesia <24 hrs, Any altered mental state, GCS >13 after 30min. 86 cases (≥15 yrs) analysed by Unden et al meta-analysis. Index test: Serum S100B(Liaison Sangtec 100)cut-off 0.08 µg/L, 0.10 µg/L from Unden et al meta-analysis. Sampling time ≤4 hrs. Gold-standard: Positive CT Scan. | Nested Cohort | Prevalence | 0.05 | Primary aim: Creatine kinase (CK) corrected S100B validation. Nested cohort: 96 subjects out of a larger cohort of 792 consecutive minor head injury cases participating in another study. Age 8-79 yrs. Selection bias. African-Americans excluded. Small sample. Not powered. No blinding mentioned. Extracranial injuries not excluded. |
AUC | 0.49 | ||||
At cut-off 0.08 ug/L: | |||||
Sensitivity | 0.8 | ||||
Specificity | 0.04 | ||||
From Unden's meta-analysis, | at cut-off 0.10 ug/L: | ||||
Sensitivity | 0.750 | ||||
Specificity | 0.650 | ||||
PPV | 0.130 | ||||
NPV | 0.900 | ||||
LR+ | 2.143 | ||||
LR- | 0.385 | ||||
Biberthaler, et al. 2006 Germany | 1,309 adults with: Isolated head injury, within 3 hrs of injury, GCS 13-15 + One or more of: Brief LOC, Amnesia, Nausea, Vomiting, Severe headache, Dizziness, Vertigo, Age >60 yrs, Intoxication, Anticoagulation. Negative controls n=540 Positive controls (GCS<13) n=55 Index test: Serum S100B (Elecsys S100, Roche)at cut-off 0.10 µg/L, taken ≤3 hrs from injury. Cut-off taken as 95th centile of negative control group Median sample time 60 min (IQR 40-80 min). Gold Standard: Positive CT Scan. | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.071 | No blinding mentioned.(Study was confirmed double blinded via personal correspondence). Possible selection bias towards earlier presenting patients, as median sampling time 60 min (IQR 40-80 min) post-trauma. Roche funded study – possible bias. |
AUC | 0.80 (95%CI 0.75-0.84) | ||||
Sensitivity | 0.99 (95%CI 0.96-1.00) | ||||
Specificity | 0.30 (95%CI 0.29-0.31) | ||||
PPV | 0.10 (95%CI 0.07-0.13) at prevalence of 0.10 | ||||
NPV | 0.9968 (95%CI 0.99-1.00) | ||||
LR+ | 1.4 | ||||
LR- | 0.03 | ||||
Potential CT use reduction | 30% | ||||
Muller K, et al. 2007 Norway | 226 adults with isolated minor head injury, within 12 hrs of injury + LOC or amnesia. GCS 13-15. No focal neurological deficit. No multiple injuries. No neurological, psychiatric, renal or liver disease. Index test: Serum S100B (LIAISON, AB Diasorin,cut-off 0.10 µg/L, sample taken ≤12 hrs from injury. Gold Standard: Positive CT Scan ≤12 hrs. | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.093 | Selection bias (high prevalence and GP referrals included). Stricter inclusion criteria: LOC or amnesia in all patients. <12 hrs inclusion but no sampling time range mentioned. Excluding cases sampled >3 hrs did not improve diagnostic properties. No blinding mentioned. Not powered enough. LR- confidence limit includes 1. |
AUC | 0.73 (95%CI 0.62-0.84) | ||||
Sensitivity | 0.95 (95%CI 0.76-1.00) | ||||
Specificity | 0.31 (95%CI 0.25-0.38) | ||||
PPV | 0.12 (95%CI 0.08-0.19) | ||||
NPV | 0.98 (95%CI 0.92-1.00) | ||||
LR+ | 1.39 (95%CI 1.21-1.58) | ||||
LR- | 0.15 (95%CI 0.02-1.04) | ||||
Unden, et al. 2009 Sweden | 1,958 patients from 6 studies. Index test: Serum S100B 0.10 µg/L. Gold Standard: Positive CT Scan. | Review | Prevalence | 0.083 | No effects model shown. Methodology whereby 6 heterogeneous studies data were added up not shown. No precision analysis. |
Sensitivity | 0.981 | ||||
Specificity | 0.346 | ||||
PPV | 0.121 | ||||
NPV | 0.995 | ||||
LR+ | 1.50 | ||||
LR- | 0.05 | ||||
Morochovic, et al. 2009 Slovak Republic | 102 patients with minor head injury, within 6 hrs of injury, GCS 13-15, Age 12-84 yrs, + One of : LOC < 30 min, Amnesia <1 hr, Unclear history, Severe headache, Trauma above clavicles, Vomiting, Focal neurological deficit, Seizure, Coagulopathy, High energy accident, Intoxication. Index test: Serum S100B (Elecsys S100 Roche), cut-off 0.10 µg/L, sample taken ≤ 6 hrs. Gold standard: Positive CT Scan (within 30 min of blood drawing). | Prospective Cohort | Prevalence | 0.176 | Small study - not powered. Selection bias. Age range 12-84 yrs. Unden’s meta-analysis used for analysing cases >15 yrs. Wide inclusion criteria. Chronic intracerebral lesions & extracerebral injuries included. Sampling time ≤6 hrs – no median and IQR mentioned. No blinding mentioned. |
Sensitivity | 0.833 (95%CI 0.58-0.96) | ||||
Specificity | 0.298 (95%CI 0.21-0.41) | ||||
PPV | 0.203 (95%CI 0.12-0.32) | ||||
NPV | 0.893 (95%CI 0.71-0.97) | ||||
LR+ | 1.186 | ||||
LR- | 0.560 | ||||
Using Unden's meta-analysis for >15yr olds: | |||||
Prevalence | 0.175 | ||||
Sensitivity | 0.882 | ||||
Specificity | 0.287 | ||||
PPV | 0.208 | ||||
NPV | 0.92 | ||||
LR+ | 1.237 | ||||
LR- | 0.411 | ||||
Bouvier, et al. 2009 France | 105 adults Age >18 yrs Isolated minor head injury within 3 hrs of injury GCS 13-15 + One of: Initial LOC, Headache, Nausea, Vomiting, Amnesia, Focal neurological deficit, Convulsions, Intoxication, Signs of injury above clavicle, Age >60 yrs, Coagulopathy. Index test: Serum S100B (Elecsys Roche), 2 cut-offs: 0.10 µg/L and 0.15µg/L, sampled ≤ 3 hrs. Gold standard: Positive CT, Blinded. | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.15 | Index test blinding not mentioned. Small study. Not powered. Selection bias. Masters classification rather than GCS used. No precision analysis. Roche realised study – possible funding bias |
AUC | 0.83 (95%CI 0.74-0.89) | ||||
At 0.15µg/L cut-off: | |||||
Sensitivity | 1.0 | ||||
Specificity | 0.5 | ||||
At 0.10µg/L cut-off | |||||
Sensitivity | 1.0 | ||||
Specificity | 0.33 | ||||
PPV | 0.21 | ||||
NPV | 1.0 | ||||
LR+ | 1.51 | ||||
LR- | 0 | ||||
Kotlyar, et al. 2010 USA | 158 (out of 346) adults with minor head injury, within 6 hrs of injury, GCS 13-15. Non-focal neurology exam. CT criteria: based on individual physician. No major trauma or prior intracranial pathology. Index test: Serum S100B (Can-Ag Diagnostics S100 EIA), lowest cut-off 0.24 µg/L, taken ≤6 hrs from injury. Gold Standard: Positive CT, <3 hrs from arrival. | Nested Case-control | Prevalence | 0.064 | Convenient design. Conveniently powered. Extracranial injury included. Criteria for CT not explained – only intent of physician. Assay insensitive - poor lower detection of 0.10 µg/L. Results based on analysis of ROC curve analysis rather than that of a 2x2 table. |
AUC | 0.643 (95%CI 0.51-0.77) | ||||
Sensitivity | 0.96 (95%CI 0.78-1.00) | ||||
Specificity | 0.13 (95%CI 0.09-0.20) | ||||
PPV | 0.15 (95%CI 0.10-0.22) | ||||
NPV | 0.95 (95%CI 0.76-1.00) | ||||
LR+ | 1.10 | ||||
LR- | 0.31 | ||||
Muller B, et al. 2010 Switzerland | 233 adults with minor head injury, GCS 13-15. All patients with head injuries had CT. Exclusions: Cancer, stroke, neurological disease, coagulopathy, intoxication, late admissions, multiple injuries. Index test: Serum S100B (Elecsys S100 Roche), cut-off 0.105 µg/L. Median sample time 77 min (IQR 60-120 min). Gold standard: Positive CT. | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.094 | Selection bias. Convenience sample - late admissions excluded. All head injuries had CT (as per local protocol). No time limit for sampling. No blinding mentioned. Specificity reported as 0.122 However specificity obtained using supplied 2x2 table is 0.317. |
Sensitivity | 0.864 | ||||
Specificity | 0.317 | ||||
PPV | 0.128 | ||||
NPV | 0.857 | ||||
Excluding 2 sampled >11.5 hrs: | |||||
Sensitivity | 0.954 | ||||
Specificity | 0.317 | ||||
PPV | 0.128 | ||||
NPV | 0.986 | ||||
LR+ | 1.396 | ||||
LR- | 0.145 | ||||
Zongo, et al. 2010 France | 1,559 patients, aged ≥15 yrs, with minor head injury within 6 hrs of injury, GCS 13-15 + One of: LOC, Amnesia, Nausea, Repeated vomiting, Severe headache, Dizziness, Vertigo, Alcohol poisoning, Anticoagulation, Age >65years. Exclusions: Non-head injury (AIS score >2). Non-traumatic neurological disease. Index test: Plasma S100B (Elecsys S100 Roche), Cut-off 0.14 µg/L - equivalent to serum S100B cut-off 0.10 µg/L. Taken ≤6 hrs . Median sample time 135 min (IQR 95-200 min) Gold Standard: Positive CT. Blinded. | Prospective cohort | Prevalence | 0.07 | S100B blinding not mentioned. Possible selection bias to early samples as median sampling time 135 min, IQR 95-200 min. |
AUC | 0.76 (95%CI 0.72-0.80) | ||||
Sensitivity | 0.982 (95%CI 0.935-0.998) | ||||
Specificity | 0.268 (95%CI 0.254-0.291) | ||||
PPV | 0.092 (95%CI 0.076-0.110) | ||||
NPV | 0.995 (95%CI 0.982-0.999) | ||||
LR+ | 1.34 (95%CI 1.29-1.40) | ||||
LR- | 0.07 (95%CI 0.02-0.26) | ||||
Potential CT Reduction | 25% |