Author, date and country | Patient group | Study type (level of evidence) | Outcomes | Key results | Study Weaknesses |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Menditto et al 2012 Italy | 97 prospectively enrolled consecutive warfarinised (for at least 1/52) patients ≥14 years old in Level 2 trauma centre without ICH on 1st CT after minor head injury (any head trauma, other than superficial injury to face, presenting with GCS 14 or 15), regardless of presence of absence of LOC, within 48 h of injury, with ISS <15 between Jan 2007–Mar 2010. Structured clinical pathway implemented, comprising 24-h period of observation and 2nd CT prior to discharge | Case series | Immediate TICH | 19/97 (16%) +ve initial CT scan | None had GCS 14 or received concomitant antiplatelet therapy. Only 5 developed ICH by 2nd CT—therefore lacking statistical power to analyse multivariate predictors of such haemorrhage. Not designed to investigate optimal period of observation before repeat CT |
Death | No deaths reported | ||||
DICH | 5/97 (6%) (95% CI 1% to 11%). Only 1 showed signs of neurological deterioration during observation period, 2/5 were discharged anyway as ICH regarded as minimal. 2 discharged after completing study protocol with –ve CT admitted 2/7 and 8/7 later with symptomatic SDH; neither required surgery. 2/5 with DICH at 24 h had initial INR >3 as did both beyond 24 h (RR DICH with INR >3 was 14 (95% CI 4 to 49)). 10 refused 2nd CT and were well during 30/7 follow-up | ||||
Admission | 3 hospitalised | ||||
Neurosurgery | 1 craniotomy | ||||
Claudia et al 2011 Italy | Medical records of 1554 adult patients with MHI evaluated by a University Hospital ED between Jan 2007 & Feb 2008 analysed retrospectively. 1410 patients (mean age 57) had at least 1 risk factor & so underwent CTB. 75 patients (5.2%) on warfarin | Case-control study | ICH | 89 patients in total (12 warfarinised) | Small sample size – 12/75 with ICH. Retrospective |
Risk factors significantly associated with ICH | Anticoagulation (OR=2.69, 95% CI 1.36-5.3, p<0.005) multiple linear regression: coefficient beta 0.078, t=2.841, p=0.005 | ||||
INR | Mean INR for warfarinised patient 2.371.04 & was significantly associated with ICH after head injury (r=0.37, p<0.005). INR values analysed using ROC curve, AUC 0.76 (95% CI 0.62-0.91), p<0.05. Showed that most effective INR cut off value was 2.43, with sensitivity of 92%, specificity of 66%, & PPV & NPV of 33% & 97% respectively | ||||
Brewer et al 2011 USA | Retrospective review of trauma registry at level II trauma centre. All trauma registry patients with MHI registered between 2004 & 2006 who were taking clopidogrel or warfarin, GCS 15 and had CTB included. Trauma registry includes all patients admitted to or consulted by the trauma service. 141 patients (mean age 79, range 36-101) | Case-control study | ICH | 41 patients (29%) diagnosed with ICH. 23/84 (27%) on warfarin. Mean presenting INR with ICH 1.97+/-0.92 compared with 2.3+/-1.2 without ICH (p=0.0987). 15/36 (41%) on clopidogrel, 3/21 (14%) on combination therapy. 39 (95%) of patients with ICH underwent reversal +/- discontinuation of clopidogrel +/- warfarin. 5 patients required surgical evacuation of ICH. 4 patients died. LOC (Wald=7.468, beta=1.179, p=0.008) predicted a +ve CT. Type of medication (warfarin, clopidogrel or aspirin) did not reach statistical significance as a predictor of a +ve CT | Patient population only includes those from trauma registry & may explain a selection bias. Relatively small numbers & retrospective design |
Major & Reed 2009 UK | 399 patients presenting to University Hospital ED with head injury & coexistent anticoagulant (warfarin) or antiplatelet (aspirin, clopidogrel or dipyridamole) therapy who were admitted to the hospital over a 3-year period (Jan 2005-Dec 2007), identified through search of electronic patient records | Cohort study | ICH | 110 patients (28% had CTB, of which 24 showed ICH. 4 died & 2 had neurosurgical intervention, but none of these were warfarinised. Of 89 patients on warfarin (including 5 also on aspirin), 27 (30%) underwent CTB, with 4 of these (15%) having ICH. There were 63 patients on warfarin who had an INR <3 (2/17 +ve scans) & 26 who had an INR >3 (2/10 +ve scans). The RR of a patient having a +ve CTB with an INR >3 compared with an INR <3 was 1.7 (95% CI 0.3-10.3) | Patients discharged from ED excluded leading to a selection bias. Retrospective. Only 44/110 patients scanned had the indication recorded. No information as to whether those with +ve scans were the ones with indications for scanning. May suggest that a significant proportion of this cohort was low risk |
Grandhi et al 2008 USA | Retrospective review of all patients evaluated at level I trauma centre between Jan 2000 & Dec 2006, to include patients >/=65 coded with a closed head injury. 52/491 (11%) were documented as taking warfarin (AC) & subsequently compared with those not anticoagulated (NAC) by 1:3 propensity matching. Mean admission INR in AC group 2.4+/-1.2 | Case-control study | Ventilator LOS (days) | 2.8+/-7.9 AC vs 1.5+/-5.8 NAC, p=0.08 | Numbers too small to determine if there was a certain level of anticoagulation for which outcomes significantly worsened ?type II error. Analysis of association between degree of anticoagulation & various measures of morbidity & mortality with larger sample populations may be able to determine a “cut-off” INR value for which the benefits of anticoagulation are outweighed by its potential complications. Retrospective |
ICU LOS (days) | 6.4+/-11.8 AC vs 4.4+/-7.3 NAC, p=0.19 | ||||
Hospital LOS (days) | 10.5+/-13.6 AC vs 9.1+/-12.1 NAC, p=0.97 | ||||
Mortality | 19/49 (38.8%) AC vs 34/147 (23.1%) NAC, p=0.04 | ||||
Pieracci et al 2007 USA | Retrospective study (2004-2006) of all trauma patients aged >/=65 (n=275) evaluated by a trauma service at a level I trauma centre who had a CTB following a head injury, including 40 WHI. 3 cohorts compared: (1) WHI with INR >/=2 (therapeutic group [TG]), n=22, 11 of whom had INR >3. Mean INR 3.33, range 2.12-7.28. (2) WHI with INR <2 (nontherapeutic group [NT]), n=18. Mean INR 1.51, range 1.00-1.96. (3) Warfarin non-users (NU), n=235. Mean INR 1.11, range 0.87-4.01 | Case-control study | Admission GCS =13 | TG 9 patients (40.9%), p=0.001; NT 2 patients (11.1%); NU 22 patients (11.9%). OR=5.13, 95% CI 1.97-13.39, p=0.001 comparing TG to NU group | Relatively small sample size, therefore, unable to fully compare warfarin users with INR 2-3 with those with INR >3. Results suggest threshold rather than a linear relationship between level of anticoagulation & risk of ICH, which is consistent with exponential scale of INR. However, both a small number of therapeutic users & a relatively narrow range of INRs among them preclude more detailed analysis. Retrospective |
ICH | TG 17 patients (77.2%), p=0.10; NT 9 patients (50.0%); NU 105 (56.8%). OR=2.59, 95% CI 0.92-7.32, p=0.07 comparing TG to NU group. Subgroup analysis revealed no difference in likelihood of ICH between those with INR 2-3 (9/11, 81.8%) & INR >3 (8/11, 72.7%) | ||||
Overall mortality | TG 7 patients (31.8%), p=0.009; NT 2 patients (11.8%); NU 17 patients (9.4%). OR=4.48, 95% CI 1.60-12.50, p=0.004 comparing TG to NU group | ||||
Mortality after ICH | TG 6 patients (35.3%), p=0.01; NT 1 patient (12.5%); NU 14 patients (13.7%). OR=3.42, 95% CI 1.09-10.76, p=0.03 comparing TG to NU group | ||||
Cohen et al 2006 USA | 77 patients from 2 trauma databases over 3-year period on warfarin with minor head inury (GCS 13-15). Average age 68. INR obtained in 57% with average 4.4 & values >3 in 47%, range 1.8-9.5. (There was another group of 49 patients who had GCS <8, average age 65. Average INR 6.5, 50% >5. Mortality 87.8%) | Cohort study | Mortality | 20 evaluated & sent home from ED. Of these, 35% had CT & all were normal. 18 returned & subsequently diagnosed with significant ICH. 2 patients died at home, 1 with autopsy-confirmed acute SDH. Overall mortality in these 20 patients was 88.8%. 45 patients admitted for observation for head injury +/- treatment of other injuries. CT obtained before admission in 70%, with only 4 showing any ICH. Within 8-18hrs of injury (mean 12hrs), 80% deteriorated to GCS <10 with ICH. Mortality in this group 84%. 12 patients presented within hours or days of injury with ICH. All underwent emergent craniotomy with a resultant mortality of 83.3% | No matched control group. Majority of patients supratherapeutically anticoagulated &, of those undergoing CT on initial presentation, only slightly >30% had any evidence of ICH. Retrospective |
Franko et al 2006 USA | Retrospective analysis of consecutive series of 1493 adult blunt head injury patients between Jan 2001 & May 2005. 159 warfarinised patients identified and were significantly older, with average age 78+/-10 & average INR 2.4+/-1.06 | Case-control study | ISS | Significantly greater 14.5+/-8.4 WHI vs 12.4+/-9.4 control, p<0.01 | They site a selection bias through education of anticoagulated patients, encouraging the seeking of early medical attention, even after seemingly minimal trauma, and so more of these patients present for evaluation. It is suggested that nontherapeutic users and non-users had similar results, but they were not compared directly. Retrospective |
LOS | Significantly longer 6.7+/-11.1 WHI vs 4.1+/-6.3 control, p<0.001 | ||||
ICH | Significantly more likely 96/159 (60.4%) WHI vs 536/1334 (40.2%) control, p<0.001, OR=2.2, 95% CI 1.6-3.1 | ||||
Mortality | Significantly higher 38/159 (23.9%) WHI vs 66/1334 (4.9%) control, p<0.001, OR=6.0, 95% CI 3.8-9.3 | ||||
Mortality in those with ICH (n=632) | Significantly higher 36/96 (37.5%) WHI vs 61/536 (11.4%) control, p<0.001, OR=4.6, 95% CI 2.8-7.6 | ||||
Effect of pre-injury anticoagulant level | Mortality & occurrence of ICH both significantly increased with increasing INR (Cochran’s linear trend p<0.001) | ||||
Age-dependent mortality | Mortality of patients >70 significantly higher than that of younger patients (p<0.001). In control group mortality significantly higher with age >70 (38/465, 8.2% vs 28/869, 3.2%) p<0.001. In WHI group mortality significantly higher with age >70 (34/133, 25.6% vs 4/26, 16.4%) p<0.001 | ||||
Ivascu et al 2005 USA | 82 WHI patients identified prospectively between Feb 2003 & April 2007, of which 19 (23%) had evidence of ICH on CTB. Compared with 2 control groups: a group identified during this protocol & a group of historic controls treated before implementation of this protocol to fast-track anticoagulation reversal | Cohort study | Age, sex, MOI, presenting GCS | Not statistically significant between groups with ICH & those without | The validity of comparing the median INR is questionable, as opposed to the comparison of mean INR. There are minimal details given of the level of coagulopathies, such as range, from which more informed conclusions could be drawn |
INR | All patients with ICH had therapeutic INR, & there was not a statistically significant difference in degree of anticoagulation between groups. Median INR 2.7 (with ICH) vs 2.5 (without), p=0.350 | ||||
ICH | 63 patients without ICH on initial CTB were admitted for 23 hours of observation. None subsequently developed ICH, including 12 patients with an INR >3.5 | ||||
Protocol implementation | Improved time from hospital presentation to physician evaluation, 50% less time in triage, significant reduction in time to obtain CTB, full anticoagulation reversal with FFP, significant reduction in rates of ICH progression & mortality | ||||
Gittleman et al 2005 USA | 89 patients being treated with heparin or coumadin who had a head injury & underwent a CTB at a level I trauma centre identified over a 4-year period (April 1997-Jan 2002) using hospital information database & neuroradiology case log. 77 taking coumadin, 8 taking heparin and 4 taking both | Cohort study | ICH | 7 patients with ICH & all had GCS <15. Included 3 cerebellar haemorrhages that were more suggestive of hypertensive rather than traumatic aetiology. No significant difference found between those with ICH & those without with respect to coagulation profile (INR 2.2+/-1.1 with ICH vs 2.5+/-1.2 without ICH) | Relatively small numbers & failed to meet sample size required by pre-test power calculation. Selection bias from only including those who had CTB. Retrospective. No breakdown of ICH patients to say who was on coumadin or heparin & presumably this could skew the mean INR values of the groups. No mortality data or follow-up data either regarding the possibility of DICH |
Mina et al 2003 USA | Prospective evaluation of all WHI patients seen in ED of level I trauma centre between Jan 2001 & Feb 2002 via a “Coumadin protocol” & compared with a group of age-matched patients over the same time period admitted with head injury but not on warfarin. 94 WHIs, mean age 77+/-11. Control group mean age 75+/-12 with normal INR values (mean 1.1+/-0.1) | Case-control study | Demographics | WHI group: no significant differences between those with & those without ICH in terms of age, gender, INR (3.2+/-1.9 with ICH vs 3.2+/-2.5 without, p=0.914), or MOI. ISS significantly higher (21.3+/-8.2 vs 3.4+/-7.1, p<0.001) & GCS significantly lower (12.0+/-4.2 vs 14.7+/-1.6, p<0.001) for patients with ICH. Control group: GCS not significantly different from WHI group but significantly higher ISS than WHI group | Well designed but no mention of impact of level of anticoagulation with regards to mortality. Apparently, most patients were therapeutic though |
ICH | 25/94 (27%) WHI group. 47/70 (67%) control group. No significant differences in age, gender, ISS, GCS or MOI | ||||
Mortality | Significantly higher WHI group 12/25 (48%) vs 5/47 (10%) control group, p<0.001. WHI group: INR similar (3.3+/-1.6 dead vs 3.0+/-2.1 survivors, p=0.585). ISS significantly lower & GCS significantly higher in survivors. Control group: ISS not significantly different but GCS significantly higher in survivors | ||||
Reynolds et al 2003 USA | 32 WHI patients over 7-year period identified from trauma registry database at level II trauma centre. Group 1 – 24 patients (mean age 82.5). All GCS 15. 8 had INR checked (mean 2.45, range 1.6-3.6). Group 2a – 4 patients. All GCS 15. Mean INR 2 (range 1.5-2.6). Group 2b – 4 patients. All GCS 15 but all became comatose within 6 hours. Mean INR 2.5 (range 2.3-3.1) | Cohort study | ICH | Failed to observe a statistically significant difference in mean INR between groups 1 & 2 (p=0.59) although only 8/24 patients from group 1 tested. No statistical difference between subgroups 2a & 2b (p=0.12). GROUP 1: Only 3 had CTB (all normal). All discharged home from ED. 22 alive 6/12 post-injury without evidence of DICH. 2 patients lost to follow-up. GROUP 2a: All had evidence of ICH on CTB. 2 had FFP & vitamin K. All treated conservatively & survived to return to their location of origin. GROUP 2b: All had evidence of ICH on CTB. All had FFP+/-vitamin K. 3 had craniotomy with decompression (2 died; 1 discharged to nursing/rehab facility) and the 4th declined intervention and subsequently died | Small observational study really with only 8 patients with ICH in 7 years. Retrospective. Would have been more informative if all of group 1 had an INR and CTB. Note that delay to reversal occurred from failure to send appropriate blood samples from patients who appeared neurologically normal after arrival in ED |
Karni et al 2001 USA | Retrospective review of approx 2000 patients admitted to trauma service of regional trauma centre between Sept 1998 & May 2000. 278 patients >65 years old with CT-documented TICH. 21 warfarinised but 5 excluded as thought more likely spontaneous ICH. Average age 78, average GCS 11, average INR 3.0 | Case-control study | Mortality | Use of FFP & cryoprecipitate to reverse coagulopathy did not impact on mortality. Nearly ½ of patients studied underwent craniotomy with 67% 30-day mortality. Overall mortality rate in WHI patients was 50% (8/16) compared with 20% (51/256) in those without coagulopathy (p=0.011). In subgroup of patients with INR >3.5, the mortality rate approached 75% | Really no data displayed to appreciate. Inadequate sample size for those with INR >3 (n approx 8) from which to draw meaningful conclusions. Retrospective |
Li et al 2001 USA | Retrospective chart review from 2 centres, May 1996-May 2000 from 1 & Jan-Dec 1998 from another. 144 WHI patients identified that had CTB. Excluded those with high-risk & moderate-risk findings. Median (IQR) age 83 (77-87) | Cohort study | Clinically important CT injury that results in change in disposition | 10 patients found to have such injuries (7%, 95% CI 3-11). No significant demographic or case-characteristic differences between groups with & without CT-identified injuries. Median (IQR) INR 2.1 (1.8-3.0) CT abnormal vs 2.1 (1.6-2.7) CT normal (p=0.6) | Retrospective design using different time periods from 2 centres for an unexplained reason. Selection bias from including only those who had CTB and no follow-up data to ensure no DICH |
Garra et al 1999 USA | 65 anticoagulated patients suffering minor head injury without LOC or acute neurological abnormality identified from retrospective chart review of electronic records from 6 community hospital EDs, including 1 trauma centre over 2-year period. Only 38 patients had PT assessment (range 12-30.7 secs) | Cohort study | Clinically significant intracranial injury | No intracranial injury found in any of the 39 patients who had a CT. Telephone follow-up of the remaining 26 patients revealed no evidence of complications related to their head injuries | Their computer system may not have identified all eligible patients leading to a selection bias. Retrospective. In the 38 patients in whom PT was checked, none was >30 secs and almost 1/3 were <14 secs, indicating that even though these patients were on warfarin, few were actually anticoagulated |
Nishijima et al, 2013, USA | Secondary aims from previously published study data (see below). Those without initial CT however excluded, leaving 982 patients on warfarin (72.7%) or clopidogrel. Mean age 75 with almost equal sex distribution. 83.6% were ground level falls and 89.5% were GCS 15 | Cohort study | Immediate TICH | 60 patients (6.1%; 95% CI 4.7% to 7.8%). None of 65 without initial CT were later diagnosed with TICH although 2 were lost to follow-up. 31/60 warfarinised. RR of warfarin 0.40 (95% CI 0.25 to 0.65) | In addition to comments for the previous paper, there were relatively few patients meeting primary outcome of immediate TICH, however, including more patients with TICH would not resolve the fact that many patients with immediate TICH appeared to have no risk factors for TICH beyond age and anticoagulant use. Also limited ability to conduct subgroup analyses by medication type (warfarin or clopidogrel) or by INR level |
In-hospital mortality after immediate TICH | 10/60 (16.7%; 95% CI 8.3% to 28.5%) | ||||
Neurosurgical intervention after immediate TICH | 12/60 (20%; 95% CI 8.3% to 28.5%) | ||||
Factors associated with immediate TICH identified by multivariate logistic regression | Vomiting (aOR 3.68; 95% CI 1.55 to 8.96) and abnormal mental status (aOR 3.08; 95% CI 1.60 to 5.4.) However, these 2 variables were absent in a substantial number of those with TICH | ||||
Rendell and Batchelor, 2013, UK | 82 WHI patients identified from 3338 CT scans requested by the ED over 2-year period (Jan 2008–Dec 2009) 72/82 (88%) patients had their INR checked | Cohort study | ICH | 12/82 (15%). RR of ICH for INR subgroups calculated: INR <2 (RR 1.89; 95% CI 0.65 to 5.55); INR 2–3 (RR 0.84; 95% CI 0.27 to 2.64); and INR >3 (RR 0.53; 95% CI 0.13 to 2.29). The greatest proportion of those with ICH (42%) had a sub-therapeutic INR. 2/12 (17%) found to have ICH despite not meeting criteria for a CT scan according to NICE. Results of INR subgroup analysis suggest that a sub-therapeutic INR may not be protective against ICH following a minor head injury | Retrospective review so never easy to capture all patients. However, a random trawl of notes over a 2-month period coded as head injury revealed no further patients. Small, but comparatively equivalent sample size, did not allow statistically significant conclusions, but did, however, yield interesting conclusions |
Neurosurgical intervention | 4/12 | ||||
Death | 3/12 |